Portuguese Margin MIS6 foraminiferal isotope and palynology data ----------------------------------------------------------------------- World Data Center for Paleoclimatology, Boulder and NOAA Paleoclimatology Program ----------------------------------------------------------------------- NOTE: PLEASE CITE ORIGINAL REFERENCE WHEN USING THIS DATA!!!!! NAME OF DATA SET: Portuguese Margin MIS6 foraminiferal isotope and palynology data LAST UPDATE: 9/7/2010 (Updated chronology for planktonic isotope data table) CONTRIBUTOR: Chronis Tzedakis, University College London IGBP PAGES/WDCA CONTRIBUTION SERIES NUMBER: 2010-084 WDC PALEO CONTRIBUTION SERIES CITATION: Portuguese Margin MIS6 foraminiferal isotope and palynology data IGBP PAGES/World Data Center for Paleoclimatology Data Contribution Series # 2010-084 NOAA/NCDC Paleoclimatology Program, Boulder CO, USA. ORIGINAL REFERENCE: Margari, V., L.C. Skinner, P.C. Tzedakis, A. Ganopolski, M. Vautravers and N.J. Shackleton. 2010. The nature of millennial-scale climate variability during the past two glacial periods. Nature Geoscience 3, 127 - 131. doi: 10.1038/ngeo740 ABSTRACT: During the last glacial period, iceberg discharges into the North Atlantic disrupted the meridional overturning circulation, leading to cooling in the Northern Hemisphere and warming in Antarctica. This asymmetric response can be explained by a bipolar see-saw mechanism, whereby changes in the strength of the meridional overturning circulation lead to changes in the interhemispheric heat transport. It is unclear, however, to what extent the response of the overturning circulation is a function of freshwater flux and boundary climate conditions. Here we use foraminiferal isotope and pollen records from the Portuguese margin to reconstruct surface- and deep-water hydrography and atmospheric changes during the last and penultimate glacial periods. When we compare our records with temperature reconstructions from Antarctica, we find that the bipolar see-saw was a characteristic feature of both glacial periods. However, the comparison also underlines the dependence of the bipolar see-saw on background climate and magnitude of iceberg discharge. It also suggests that an intensified hydrological cycle may lead to a weaker overturning circulation with a smaller disruption threshold and extended North Atlantic stadial durations. ADDITIONAL REFERENCES: Vautravers, M. and N.J. Shackleton. 2006. Centennial scale surface hydrology off Portugal during Marine Isotope Stage 3: Insights from planktonic foraminiferal fauna variability. Paleoceanography 21, PA3004. Shackleton, N.J., M.A. Hall, and E. Vincent. 2000. Phase relationships between millennial-scale events 64,000–24,000 years ago. Paleoceanography, 15(6), 565–569. doi:10.1029/2000PA000513. GEOGRAPHIC REGION: Eastern North Atlantic off Portugal PERIOD OF RECORD: 193 - 136 Kyr BP FUNDING SOURCE: NERC (NE/C514758/1), EU (EV K2-CT-2000-00089) and the Royal Society. DESCRIPTION: Core MD01-2444 (37°33.68N; 10°08.53W; 2,637 m water depth; 27.45 m in length) MD01-2444 MIS3 isotope and faunal data in Vautravers and Shackleton, 2006. DATA: A detailed chronological framework for the MIS6 section of MD01-2444 was developed by aligning its benthic d18O record to the deuterium content (dD) in the Dome C (EDC) ice core of the European Project for Ice Coring in Antarctica (EPICA), plotted on the new EDC3 timescale (Parrenin et al., 2007), on the basis of the implications of the study by Shackleton et al. (2000). A minimum tuning approach was adopted, using event stratigraphy to align the most obvious “peaks” in the two records Depth(m) Age Control points (ka) 22.02 136.1 22.5 141.686 23.7 149.586 24.48 159.105 24.72 162.476 25.32 168.273 25.71 172.009 25.95 175.461 26.01 177.065 27.03 188.009 27.3 192.231 TABLE 1: Depth (m) EDC3 Age (ka) d18Oplanktonic (G. bulloides) 22.02 136.100 2.94 22.05 136.449 2.35 22.08 136.798 1.92 22.11 137.147 2.07 22.14 137.497 2.03 22.17 137.846 2.37 22.20 138.195 1.92 22.23 138.544 2.24 22.26 138.893 2.22 22.29 139.242 2.46 22.32 139.591 2.42 22.35 139.940 2.56 22.38 140.290 2.53 22.41 140.639 2.71 22.44 140.988 3.07 22.47 141.337 2.71 22.50 141.686 2.51 22.53 141.884 2.6 22.56 142.081 2.19 22.59 142.279 2.3 22.62 142.476 2.27 22.65 142.674 2.17 22.68 142.871 2.26 22.71 143.069 2.21 22.74 143.266 2.3 22.77 143.464 2.47 22.80 143.661 2.57 22.83 143.859 2.07 22.86 144.056 2.77 22.89 144.254 2.76 22.92 144.451 2.75 22.95 144.649 2.95 22.98 144.846 2.75 23.01 145.044 2.83 23.04 145.241 2.83 23.07 145.439 2.71 23.10 145.636 2.77 23.13 145.834 2.59 23.16 146.031 2.61 23.19 146.229 2.78 23.22 146.426 2.61 23.25 146.624 2.95 23.28 146.821 2.85 23.31 147.019 2.71 23.34 147.216 2.79 23.37 147.414 2.66 23.40 147.611 2.91 23.43 147.809 2.97 23.46 148.006 2.91 23.49 148.204 2.8 23.52 148.401 2.63 23.55 148.599 2.37 23.58 148.796 2.44 23.64 149.191 2.83 23.67 149.389 2.49 23.70 149.586 23.73 149.952 2.41 23.79 150.684 2.78 23.82 151.050 2.7 23.85 151.417 2.65 23.88 151.783 2.47 23.91 152.149 2.78 23.97 152.881 2.9 24.00 153.247 3.01 24.03 153.613 2.84 24.06 153.979 2.81 24.09 154.346 2.88 24.12 154.712 2.85 24.15 155.078 2.91 24.18 155.444 2.75 24.21 155.810 2.72 24.24 156.176 2.48 24.27 156.542 2.66 24.30 156.908 2.53 24.33 157.274 2.28 24.36 157.641 2.51 24.39 158.007 2.15 24.42 158.373 1.99 24.45 158.739 1.96 24.48 159.105 2.31 24.51 159.526 2.46 24.54 159.948 2.29 24.57 160.369 2.23 24.60 160.791 2.22 24.63 161.212 2.28 24.66 161.633 2.32 24.69 162.055 2.63 24.72 162.476 2.68 24.75 162.766 2.19 24.78 163.056 2.24 24.81 163.346 2.21 24.84 163.635 2.11 24.87 163.925 2.11 24.90 164.215 2.02 24.93 164.505 1.85 24.99 165.085 1.96 25.02 165.375 1.75 25.05 165.664 1.75 25.08 165.954 1.96 25.14 166.534 1.5 25.17 166.824 1.71 25.20 167.114 1.27 25.23 167.403 1.39 25.26 167.693 1.43 25.29 167.983 1.21 25.32 168.273 2.15 25.35 168.560 2.14 25.38 168.848 2.18 25.41 169.135 1.93 25.44 169.423 2 25.47 169.710 2.47 25.50 169.997 2.28 25.53 170.285 2.39 25.56 170.572 2.18 25.59 170.859 2.13 25.62 171.147 1.89 25.65 171.434 1.29 25.68 171.722 1.49 25.71 172.009 2.27 25.74 172.441 2.2 25.77 172.872 2.15 25.80 173.304 2.21 25.83 173.735 2.24 25.86 174.167 1.86 25.89 174.598 2.35 25.92 175.030 2.07 25.94 175.317 0.8 25.95 175.461 25.97 175.996 1.25 25.98 176.263 1.84 26.00 176.798 1.43 26.01 177.065 2.31 26.03 177.280 2.16 26.04 177.387 2.27 26.06 177.601 2.03 26.07 177.709 2.07 26.09 177.923 2.17 26.13 178.353 2.41 26.16 178.674 2.34 26.19 178.996 2.31 26.22 179.318 2.18 26.25 179.640 1.45 26.28 179.962 2.01 26.31 180.284 1.63 26.37 180.928 1.56 26.40 181.249 1.73 26.43 181.571 1.64 26.46 181.893 1.69 26.49 182.215 1.82 26.52 182.537 1.78 26.55 182.859 1.57 26.58 183.181 1.57 26.61 183.503 1.67 26.64 183.825 1.86 26.67 184.146 1.76 26.70 184.468 1.64 26.73 184.790 1.42 26.76 185.112 1.41 26.79 185.434 1.3 26.85 186.078 0.81 26.88 186.400 0.82 26.91 186.721 0.77 26.94 187.043 1 26.97 187.365 1.45 27.00 187.687 2.03 27.03 188.009 2.05 27.06 188.478 1.87 27.09 188.947 2.2 27.12 189.416 2.32 27.15 189.885 2.02 27.18 190.355 1.71 27.21 190.824 1.3 27.24 191.293 1.13 27.30 192.231 1.07 27.33 192.442 1.08 27.36 192.653 1.69 27.39 192.865 1.77 27.42 193.076 1.79 TABLE 2: Depth (m) EDC3 Age (ka) mean d18Obenthic 22.02 136.1 4.846 22.05 136.449 5.0339 22.08 136.798 5.0184 22.11 137.147 5.0053 22.14 137.497 4.8626 22.17 137.846 5.0479 22.2 138.195 4.9731 22.23 138.544 5.0041 22.26 138.893 5.0032 22.29 139.242 5.0247 22.32 139.591 5.0332 22.35 139.94 5.0709 22.38 140.29 4.9651 22.44 140.988 5.0519 22.47 141.337 5.0623 22.5 141.686 4.63 22.53 141.884 4.76 22.56 142.081 4.84 22.62 142.476 5.01 22.65 142.674 4.83 22.68 142.871 4.83 22.71 143.069 4.925 22.74 143.266 5 22.77 143.464 4.92 22.8 143.661 4.91 22.83 143.859 4.87 22.86 144.056 4.49 22.92 144.451 4.9 22.98 144.846 4.99 23.01 145.044 4.775 23.04 145.241 4.8361 23.07 145.439 4.9765 23.1 145.636 4.7825 23.13 145.834 4.8182 23.16 146.031 4.8824 23.19 146.229 4.7587 23.22 146.426 4.7133 23.25 146.624 4.451 23.28 146.821 4.7856 23.31 147.019 4.8062 23.34 147.216 4.5946 23.37 147.414 4.8798 23.43 147.809 4.6114 23.46 148.006 4.7822 23.49 148.204 4.8561 23.52 148.401 4.8503 23.55 148.599 4.762 23.58 148.796 4.8943 23.64 149.191 4.6067 23.67 149.389 4.5981 23.7 149.586 4.3503 23.73 149.952 4.6905 23.76 150.318 4.7844 23.79 150.684 4.853 23.82 151.05 4.7661 23.88 151.783 4.7229 23.91 152.149 4.7143 23.94 152.515 4.7755 23.97 152.881 4.7469 24 153.247 4.7368 24.03 153.613 4.7642 24.06 153.979 4.8132 24.09 154.346 4.7128 24.12 154.712 4.6595 24.15 155.078 4.7808 24.18 155.444 4.7929 24.21 155.81 4.722 24.24 156.176 4.9228 24.27 156.542 4.8395 24.3 156.908 4.769 24.33 157.274 4.8969 24.36 157.641 4.8304 24.39 158.007 4.9077 24.42 158.373 4.9253 24.45 158.739 4.8997 24.48 159.105 4.4491 24.51 159.526 4.5567 24.54 159.948 4.813 24.57 160.369 4.9123 24.6 160.791 4.8434 24.63 161.212 4.7927 24.66 161.633 4.198 24.69 162.055 4.4349 24.72 162.476 4.274 24.75 162.766 4.4195 24.78 163.056 4.7002 24.81 163.346 4.4751 24.84 163.635 4.5734 24.87 163.925 4.704 24.9 164.215 4.7721 24.93 164.505 4.7555 24.99 165.085 4.7533 25.02 165.375 4.6993 25.05 165.664 4.7959 25.08 165.954 4.6409 25.11 166.244 4.6046 25.14 166.534 4.653 25.17 166.824 4.5614 25.2 167.114 4.529 25.23 167.403 4.5742 25.26 167.693 4.4024 25.29 167.983 4.462 25.32 168.273 3.9222 25.35 168.56 4.1661 25.38 168.848 4.2962 25.41 169.135 4.3282 25.44 169.423 4.3464 25.47 169.71 4.407 25.5 169.997 4.5378 25.53 170.285 4.58 25.56 170.572 4.59 25.59 170.859 4.625 25.65 171.434 4.465 25.68 171.722 4.5333 25.71 172.009 4.23 25.74 172.441 4.4433 25.77 172.872 4.49 25.8 173.304 4.66 25.83 173.735 4.74 25.86 174.167 4.61 25.89 174.598 4.59 25.92 175.03 4.6167 25.95 175.461 4.5081 25.98 176.263 4.6891 26.01 177.065 4.1634 26.04 177.387 4.4405 26.07 177.709 4.376 26.1 178.031 4.5431 26.13 178.353 4.4838 26.16 178.674 4.3537 26.19 178.996 4.5395 26.22 179.318 4.479 26.25 179.64 4.6461 26.28 179.962 4.7229 26.31 180.284 4.7401 26.34 180.606 4.7516 26.37 180.928 4.6712 26.4 181.249 4.6688 26.43 181.571 4.6772 26.46 181.893 4.642 26.49 182.215 4.7053 26.52 182.537 4.599 26.55 182.859 4.7003 26.58 183.181 4.6868 26.61 183.503 4.6015 26.64 183.825 4.5528 26.67 184.146 4.4994 26.7 184.468 4.5151 26.73 184.79 4.476 26.76 185.112 4.3519 26.79 185.434 4.3795 26.82 185.756 4.2806 26.85 186.078 4.1411 26.88 186.4 4.1704 26.91 186.721 4.0889 26.94 187.043 4.0107 26.97 187.365 3.7549 27 187.687 3.6538 27.03 188.009 3.5935 27.06 188.478 3.7962 27.09 188.947 3.4219 27.12 189.416 4.1604 27.15 189.885 4.3604 27.18 190.355 4.1185 27.21 190.824 4.2661 27.24 191.293 4.1171 27.27 191.762 4.0579 27.3 192.231 3.995 27.33 192.442 3.8857 27.36 192.653 4.2082 27.39 192.865 3.9808 27.42 193.076 4.1748 27.45 193.287 4.0978 TABLE 3: Depth (m) EDC3 Age (ka) Temperate tree pollen % (Eurosiberian+Mediterranean trees and shrubs) Mediterranean pollen % (Evergreen Quercus+Olea+Phillyrea+Pistacia) 22.02 136.1 3.31 1.33 22.05 136.449 7.89 1.75 22.08 136.798 7.27 0 22.11 137.147 2.73 0 22.14 137.497 12.5 3.29 22.17 137.846 6 0.67 22.2 138.195 4.85 0 22.23 138.544 11.82 2.73 22.26 138.893 3.92 0.65 22.29 139.242 6.48 0.93 22.32 139.591 1.75 0 22.35 139.94 7.89 1.75 22.38 140.29 4.67 2 22.41 140.639 5.77 0.96 22.44 140.988 3.77 0 22.47 141.337 4.55 0.91 22.5 141.686 5.57 0.66 22.53 141.884 4.2 0.84 22.56 142.081 2.55 1.27 22.59 142.279 4 2 22.62 142.476 2.48 0 22.65 142.674 4.52 0 22.68 142.871 4.64 0.66 22.71 143.069 7.14 0 22.74 143.266 1.33 0 22.77 143.464 6.09 1.74 22.8 143.661 1.33 0 22.83 143.859 4.35 0.87 22.86 144.056 4.61 1.97 22.89 144.254 9.01 2.7 22.92 144.451 4.32 0 22.95 144.649 7.21 0 22.98 144.846 2.8 0.94 23.01 145.044 4.76 0.95 23.04 145.241 6.62 1.33 23.07 145.439 8.33 0.93 23.1 145.636 2.91 0 23.13 145.834 2.63 0 23.16 146.031 7.33 0.67 23.19 146.229 4.51 0 23.22 146.426 2.42 1.61 23.25 146.624 5 0 23.28 146.821 2.63 0 23.31 147.019 2.94 0 23.34 147.216 1.99 0 23.37 147.414 7.62 0 23.4 147.611 5.33 0.67 23.43 147.809 2.94 0.98 23.46 148.006 1.97 0.66 23.49 148.204 5.83 0 23.52 148.401 4 0.67 23.55 148.599 10 2.73 23.58 148.796 15.34 1.84 23.61 148.994 13.73 0 23.64 149.191 4 0 23.67 149.389 8.33 0.93 23.7 149.586 6 1.33 23.73 149.952 2.73 0 23.76 150.318 4.59 0.92 23.79 150.684 6.67 1.9 23.82 151.05 10.96 1.99 23.85 151.417 5.71 0.95 23.88 151.783 3.64 0.91 23.91 152.149 2.73 0 23.94 152.515 0 0 23.97 152.881 0.93 0 24 153.247 9.43 2.83 24.03 153.613 3.92 0 24.09 154.346 0.95 0 24.15 155.078 1.87 0 24.18 155.444 0.65 0 24.21 155.81 2.46 0 24.24 156.176 4.9 1.96 24.27 156.542 5.09 0.85 24.3 156.908 1.33 0 24.33 157.274 4.31 0.86 24.36 157.641 2.86 0 24.39 158.007 5.56 1.85 24.42 158.373 3.23 0.64 24.45 158.739 22.64 7.55 24.48 159.105 3.33 0.67 24.51 159.526 1.96 0 24.54 159.948 2.35 0 24.6 160.791 6 0.67 24.63 161.212 12.82 2.56 24.66 161.633 13.07 8.5 24.69 162.055 3.92 0 24.72 162.476 9 2 24.75 162.766 8.92 2.82 24.78 163.056 12.38 1.9 24.81 163.346 8.77 4.39 24.84 163.635 2 0 24.87 163.925 13.51 3.38 24.9 164.215 9.87 3.95 24.93 164.505 12.4 1.65 24.96 164.795 8 2 24.99 165.085 11.11 1.59 25.02 165.375 14.57 7.28 25.05 165.664 18.18 3.64 25.08 165.954 11 1 25.11 166.244 18.58 2.65 25.14 166.534 23.87 5.81 25.17 166.824 25.71 3.81 25.2 167.114 17 3 25.23 167.403 15 2 25.26 167.693 19.47 7.92 25.29 167.983 30.48 3.81 25.32 168.273 11.77 2.94 25.35 168.56 9.82 2.68 25.41 169.135 10.46 0 25.44 169.423 11.01 0.92 25.47 169.71 9 1 25.5 169.997 9.26 3.7 25.53 170.285 19.61 5.23 25.56 170.572 9.8 1.96 25.59 170.859 11 1 25.62 171.147 17.59 2.78 25.65 171.434 24.25 2.66 25.68 171.722 19.25 2.82 25.71 172.009 21.39 4.97 25.77 172.872 12.7 0.65 25.8 173.304 12.38 1.9 25.83 173.735 18.55 4.84 25.86 174.167 24.44 3.33 25.89 174.598 12 2 25.95 175.461 30.67 5.33 25.98 176.263 29.52 9.52 26.01 177.065 21.05 3.95 26.07 177.709 13.08 1.87 26.13 178.353 8.25 0.66 26.16 178.674 10.58 0.96 26.19 178.996 17.88 3.97 26.22 179.318 22.02 1.84 26.25 179.64 18.42 1.97 26.28 179.962 18.69 2.8 26.31 180.284 16.72 2.62 26.34 180.606 17.76 2.8 26.37 180.928 15.23 2.65 26.4 181.249 14.91 2.63 26.43 181.571 15.52 0.86 26.46 181.893 10.62 4.43 26.49 182.215 10.75 1.3 26.52 182.537 16.67 5.56 26.55 182.859 22.03 5.09 26.58 183.181 15.52 2.59 26.61 183.503 7.24 0.66 26.64 183.825 5.64 0.81 26.67 184.146 8.74 0 26.7 184.468 7.84 1.96 26.73 184.79 10 0.67 26.76 185.112 12.73 0.91 26.79 185.434 15.39 0.86 26.82 185.756 20.79 1.98 26.85 186.078 17.1 2.63 26.88 186.4 26.13 3.6 26.91 186.721 14.42 1.92 26.94 187.043 21.82 4.55 26.97 187.365 8 0 27 187.687 27.89 4.81 27.03 188.009 24.4 6.7 27.06 188.478 28.57 6.67 27.09 188.947 21.36 1.94 27.12 189.416 10.38 0 27.15 189.885 9.35 0 27.18 190.355 18.4 1.6 27.21 190.824 23.81 3.81 27.24 191.293 31.37 5.88 27.27 191.762 38.83 2.91 27.3 192.231 27.33 192.442 31.07 4.85 27.36 192.653 26 5 27.39 192.865 15 2 27.42 193.076 8.91 1.98