# Kiritimati Coral Isotope Data #----------------------------------------------------------------------- # World Data Center for Paleoclimatology, Boulder # and # NOAA Paleoclimatology Program #----------------------------------------------------------------------- # NOTE: Please cite Publication, and Online_Resource and date accessed when using these data. # If there is no publication information, please cite Investigators, Title, and Online_Resource and date accessed. # # Online_Resource: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/study/1847 # # Original_Source_URL: http://www1.ncdc.noaa.gov/pub/data/paleo/coral/east_pacific/readme_kiritimati.txt # Original_Source_URL: http://www1.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/image/coral/kirit13c.gif # Original_Source_URL: http://www1.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/image/coral/kirit18o.gif # Original_Source_URL: http://www1.ncdc.noaa.gov/pub/data/paleo/coral/east_pacific/kiritimati1.txt # # Description/Documentation lines begin with # # Data lines have no # # # Archive: Corals and Sclerosponges #-------------------- # Contribution_Date # Date: 1998-10-01 #-------------------- # Title # Study_Name: Kiritimati Island - Data #-------------------- # Investigators # Investigators: Evans, M.N.; Fairbanks, R.G.; Rubenstone, J.L. #-------------------- # Description_and_Notes # Description: The following is excerpted from Evans et al., J.Geophys. Res., in review, 1998 (please see this paper for references made in this readme file): Proxy climate data derived from the isotopic composition and chemistry of aragonite formed by massive reef corals provide a supplementary data set for the study of the tropical near-surface climate [Cole et al., 1993; Dunbar et al., 1994; Linsley et al., 1994; Tudhope et al., 1995; Charles et al., 1997]. Given constant sea water o18 and biological processes, variability in the oxygen isotopic composition (o18) of coralline aragonite is a function of the sea surface temperature in which the coral secreted its skeleton [Epstein et al., 1953; Weber and Woodhead, 1972; McConnaughey, 1989]. However, coral o18 also records changes in the o18 of sea water [Cole et al., 1993; Linsley et al., 1994; McCulloch et al., 1994] if freshwater flux variance is significant. The Strontium:Calcium (Sr/Ca) ratio in corals has been shown to be a function of sea surface temperature as well, with minimal sea water Sr/Ca influence [Weber, 1973; Schneider and Smith, 1979; Beck et al., 1992; DeVilliers et al., 1994; Shen et al., 1996]. Application of these two proxy measurements in tandem has been used to distinguish sea water o18 and sea surface temperature anomalies recorded on the Great Barrier Reef during the 1982-3 El Nino-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) event [McCulloch et al., 1994]. We made measurements of stable isotopic composition (o18 and c13) and Sr/Ca on a coral collected live from Kiritimati (Christmas) Island (157.3 W, 2 N), in the Republic of Kiribati. Kiritimati lies at the eastern edge of the western Pacific warm pool and just west of the NINO3 box (Fig. 1). The seasonal range of sea surface temperature (SST) is less than 1.2 degrees C. Because the seasonal cycle is modest, ENSO-induced warm and cold phase sea surface temperature anomalies of +/-3 degrees C are prominent [Bjerknes, 1969; Wyrtki, 1975; Wyrtki, 1985; Philander, 1990]. By contrast, ENSO-driven precipitation anomalies are moderate in magnitude and brief in duration, creating a minor change in sea water o18 due to enhanced rainfall [Ropelewski and Halpert, 1987] and eastward advection of lower salinity water [Picaut et al., 1996]. Thus, Kiritimati is an ideal location from which to monitor the thermal signal associated with the full ENSO cycle and should record features similar to those in the NINO3 region. Data and Methods: Stable isotope data Coral PP7-3 was collected live and cored at South West Point, Kiritimati Island, at 9 meters depth in March 1994. The coral has been identified as Porites sp., probably P. australiensis, possibly P. lobata [D. Potts, UCSC, pers. comm.]. The core was slabbed along the growth axis and X-radiographed for densitometry study; slabs were then ultrasonically cleaned in de-ionized water and dried at 50 degrees C prior to sampling. Samples for oxygen and carbon isotope analyses were drilled from the slab at 0.5 mm intervals starting from just below the most recent growth and extending to a maximum depth of 1004 mm. A precise age model was recoverable for the upper 839.5 mm. Samples were drilled from lines chosen parallel to the axis of maximum growth to avoid non-temporal (i.e. potential differential growth-related) isotopic effects [McConnaughey, 1989]. X-ray diffraction analyses of drilled and chipped coral aragonite verify that samples were 100% aragonite after drilling. Sequential isotopic analyses were made using a Finnigan MAT-251 gas source mass spectrometer coupled to a Carousel-48 automated sample preparation device. Measurement precisions (1-sigma) were +/-0.06 per mil and +/- 0.04 per mil for o18 and c13 analyses, based on analysis of a lab standard; sample replication over the 1981-1987 period (see section on Sr/Ca data below) gives an external precision of +/- 0.09 per mil in the o18 time series shown in Fig. 2. All stable isotope measurements are reported relative to the PDB standard. We use the strongly periodic c13 record to provide an age model for time series analysis of the o18 data. The carbon isotopic composition of coralline aragonite varies with seasonal changes in insolation, reproductive activity, and changes in the c13 of [sigma CO2] of sea water [Fairbanks and Dodge, 1979, Patzold, 1984, Gagan et al., 1994, Gagan et al., 1996]. The carbon isotope record from coral PP7-3 (Fig. 2) shows a series of regular c13 enrichments, which correspond to thin low density bands. These enrichments are probably too large to be explained entirely by variability of c13 of sea water [ sigma CO2] [Swart et al., 1996] or to be solely related to seasonal insolation variability [Fairbanks and Dodge, 1979]. However, a model which invokes the drawdown of carbon-12 within the coral polyp by production of gametes during a brief period of each year, a process called mass spawning [Babcock et al., 1986, Gagan et al., 1994; Gagan et al., 1996], may explain the annual enrichments we observe in the carbon isotopic record. There are no published accounts of the timing of mass spawning events in the central Pacific. We assume that such events take place in April of each year, at the onset of the April-September insolation maximum at Kiritimati. Intermittently in the PP7-3 record, single years do not display a c13 enrichment, perhaps due to sub-optimal coral reproductive conditions. In these cases we use the same growth rate as the previous and subsequent years to continue the age model, an assumption consistent with an age model based on densitometric observations (Figure 2, top) and relatively constant extension rate (Figure 4). By these criteria, the length of record extends from September 1993 back to April 1938 (Figs. 2,4). The high (0.5mm) sampling resolution enabled us to obtain 25-35 samples per annual band and achieve a chronology with biweekly to monthly resolution. The chronology we construct is in good agreement with annual age determinations based on X-radiography of the sampled slab, and with an age model based on a constant growth rate assumption (Fig. 4). Uncertainty in such an age model might be expected to vary with time before present; therefore a single error estimate for the entire time period is unsatisfactory. Since the timing of mass spawning at Kiritimati has not been observed, we conservatively assume an initial age model error of +/- 1/2 year, and we estimate the age model error as a function of the absence of the annual \delc\ chronometer. The mean extension rate is 14 mm/yr, with a standard deviation of 1.5 mm/yr (11%). Therefore, we estimate age model uncertainty for each year within the preceding five decades as (0.5 + 2*n*sigma(growth rate) years, where n is the number of years in that decade in which the c13 enrichment is absent. These errors range from +/-0.5 to +/-1 year per year of age model (Fig. 4). We believe that uncertainty in the age model is well represented by these estimates. Initially we derived cumulative age model error estimates, but it was clear by this model that these error estimates were too large in the earlier half of the record, and too small in the more recent half. A better error representation was obtained with the error model below, which acknowledges that periods of consistently periodic c13 pulses provides better age control than periods with more intermittent reproductive activity. Subsequent intercomparison of the Kiritimati o18 record with the historical SST analysis by [Kaplan et al. 1998] suggests our age model estimates are probably appropriate. Data and Methods: Sr/Ca data Sr/Ca may be the preferred proxy for the purpose of SST reconstructions, since unlike o18, Sr/Ca variability is solely a function of SST. However, since analysis of \delo\ is more easily automated, requires less sample preparation and is 10-20 times faster than measurement of Sr/Ca by thermal ionization mass spectrometry (TIMS), we use limited, high precision TIMS Sr/Ca measurements to confirm the interpretation of the Kiritimati o18 time series as primarily driven by regional SST anomaly. Based on the carbon isotope age model, we resampled the 1981-1987 period (Fig. 3A). Samples were drilled at 1 mm intervals in a transect parallel to the line chosen for the high resolution stable isotopic measurements described above. The samples created were split into two portions: one for replicate stable isotope analysis and one for Sr/Ca analysis. Stable isotope and Sr/Ca sample sizes were 70-120 micrograms and 130-250 micrograms, respectively. The replicate stable isotope measurements were used to verify the chronology for the Sr/Ca data and to assess the reproducibility of the oxygen isotope anomaly record. Stable isotope measurements were made using the previously described procedures. Sr and Ca concentrations were measured using the isotope dilution technique on a VG Sector thermal ionization mass spectrometer, using enriched Sr-84 and Ca-43 spikes. In-run isotopic fractionation was corrected using measured Sr-86/Sr-88 and Ca-42/Ca-44 and an exponential fractionation law [Russell et al., 1978]. Duplicate or triplicate runs were made on each Sr/Ca sample and averaged. The standard error (2-sigma) on the Sr/Ca measurements is less than +/-0.03 mmol/mol, based on internal precision, duplicate analyses, and replicates; this translates into an SST error estimate of less than +/-0.5 degrees C. # #-------------------- # Publication # Authors: Evans, M.N.; Fairbanks, R.G.; Rubenstone, J.L. # Published_Date_or_Year: 1998 # Published_Title: A Proxy Index of ENSO Teleconnections # Journal_Name: Nature # Volume: 394 # Edition: # Issue: # Pages: 732-733 # DOI: # Online_Resource: # Full_Citation: Evans, M.N., R.G. Fairbanks and J.L. Rubenstone, A Proxy Index of ENSO Teleconnections, Nature 394:732-733, 1998. # Abstract: #-------------------- # Publication # Authors: Evans, M.N.; Fairbanks, R.G.; Rubenstone, J.L. # Published_Date_or_Year: 1998 # Published_Title: The Thermal Oceanographic Signal of ENSO Constructed from a Kiritimati Island Coral # Journal_Name: J. Geophys. Res. # Volume: 104 # Edition: # Issue: C6 # Pages: 13409-13421 # DOI: # Online_Resource: http://rainbow.ldeo.columbia.edu/~mevans/preprints/thermal_signal/ # Full_Citation: Evans, M.N., R.G. Fairbanks and J.L. Rubenstone, The Thermal Oceanographic Signal of ENSO Constructed from a Kiritimati Island Coral, J. Geophys. Res., 1998 # Abstract: #------------------ # Funding_Agency # Funding_Agency_Name: National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA, USA) # Grant: #------------------ # Funding_Agency # Funding_Agency_Name: National Aeronautical and Space Administration (NASA, USA) # Grant: #------------------ # Site_Information # Site_Name: Kiritimati (Christmas) Island, Republic of Kiribati # Location: Ocean>Pacific Ocean>Central Pacific Ocean>Kiribati # Country: Kiritimati (Christmas) Island, Republic of Kiribati # Northernmost_Latitude: 2.0 # Southernmost_Latitude: 2.0 # Easternmost_Longitude: -157.3 # Westernmost_Longitude: -157.3 # Elevation: -9 m #------------------ # Data_Collection # Collection_Name: 98kiri01a # Earliest_Year: 1938 # Most_Recent_Year: 1993 # Time_Unit: AD # Core_Length: 0.8395 m # Notes: DATA PRECISION (1 standard deviation): COLUMN 1: 1938-1945: +/- 0.5 year; 1946-1955: +/- 0.7 year; 1956-1965: +/- 0.8 year; 1966-1975: +/- 0.8 year; 1976-1985: +/- 0.8 year; 1986-1993: +/- 0.7 year. COLUMN 2: +/- 0.09 per mil COLUMN 3: +/- 0.06 per mil #------------------ # Species # Species_Name: Porites sp. # Common_Name: #------------------ # Chronology_Information # Chronology: # #---------------- # Variables # # Data variables follow that are preceded by "##" in columns one and two. # Data line variables format: Variables list, one per line, shortname-9 components: what, material, error, units, seasonality, archive, detail, method, C or N for Character or Numeric data) # ## age age, , ,years AD, , , , ,N ## d13C delta 13C, Porites sp., , permil VPDB, , Corals and Sclerosponges, , ,N ## d18O delta 18O, Porites sp., , permil VPDB, , Corals and Sclerosponges, , ,N # #---------------- # Data: # Data lines follow (have no #) # Data line format - tab-delimited text, variable short name as header # Missing Values: NAN age d13C d18O 1938.292 -2.391 -4.272 1938.375 -2.705 -4.355 1938.458 -2.821 -4.343 1938.542 -3.089 -4.603 1938.625 -3.068 -4.534 1938.708 -3.232 -4.644 1938.792 -3.015 -4.607 1938.875 -2.833 -4.543 1938.958 -3.152 -4.802 1939.042 -2.902 -4.694 1939.125 -2.496 -4.685 1939.208 -2.280 -4.807 1939.292 -1.963 -4.738 1939.375 -2.235 -4.745 1939.458 -2.096 -4.764 1939.542 -2.204 -4.656 1939.625 -2.710 -4.698 1939.708 -2.386 -4.607 1939.792 -2.602 -4.796 1939.875 -2.518 -4.833 1939.958 -2.291 -4.802 1940.042 -2.385 -4.810 1940.125 -2.058 -4.951 1940.208 -1.871 -4.910 1940.292 -1.514 -4.900 1940.375 -1.649 -4.875 1940.458 -1.756 -4.979 1940.542 -2.059 -5.036 1940.625 -2.082 -5.027 1940.708 -2.107 -5.031 1940.792 -1.888 -5.033 1940.875 -2.390 -5.145 1940.958 -1.945 -5.161 1941.042 -2.002 -5.233 1941.125 -2.018 -5.059 1941.208 -1.900 -5.001 1941.292 -1.041 -4.813 1941.375 -1.471 -4.858 1941.458 -1.470 -4.870 1941.542 -1.677 -4.968 1941.625 -1.952 -5.042 1941.708 -2.011 -4.924 1941.792 -1.908 -4.970 1941.875 -2.027 -4.976 1941.958 -1.996 -4.953 1942.042 -1.913 -4.771 1942.125 -2.394 -4.665 1942.208 -2.082 -4.765 1942.292 -1.026 -4.461 1942.375 -1.783 -4.774 1942.458 -1.247 -4.676 1942.542 -1.806 -4.531 1942.625 -2.176 -4.506 1942.708 -2.046 -4.400 1942.792 -2.181 -4.478 1942.875 -2.243 -4.283 1942.958 -2.425 -4.243 1943.042 -2.524 -4.237 1943.125 -2.587 -4.446 1943.208 -2.540 -4.550 1943.292 -2.383 -4.400 1943.375 -1.991 -4.567 1943.458 -2.279 -4.736 1943.542 -2.113 -4.699 1943.625 -2.342 -4.668 1943.708 -2.495 -4.427 1943.792 -2.372 -4.418 1943.875 -2.512 -4.396 1943.958 -2.368 -4.423 1944.042 -2.621 -4.499 1944.125 -2.676 -4.598 1944.208 -2.460 -4.478 1944.292 -1.940 -4.528 1944.375 -2.042 -4.750 1944.458 -2.041 -4.679 1944.542 -2.193 -4.545 1944.625 -2.246 -4.507 1944.708 -2.319 -4.441 1944.792 -2.732 -4.375 1944.875 -2.717 -4.392 1944.958 -2.609 -4.291 1945.042 -2.549 -4.337 1945.125 -2.559 -4.375 1945.208 -2.481 -4.359 1945.292 -1.512 -4.213 1945.375 -2.196 -4.492 1945.458 -2.325 -4.427 1945.542 -2.345 -4.459 1945.625 -2.339 -4.521 1945.708 -2.743 -4.329 1945.792 -2.707 -4.283 1945.875 -3.019 -4.293 1945.958 -2.959 -4.359 1946.042 -3.120 -4.328 1946.125 -2.692 -4.479 1946.208 -2.511 -4.404 1946.292 -1.107 -4.265 1946.375 -2.500 -4.633 1946.458 -2.399 -4.564 1946.542 -2.306 -4.609 1946.625 -2.361 -4.614 1946.708 -2.509 -4.628 1946.792 -2.524 -4.582 1946.875 -2.738 -4.442 1946.958 -2.712 -4.403 1947.042 -2.807 -4.494 1947.125 -3.177 -4.628 1947.208 -2.194 -3.748 1947.292 -1.360 -4.188 1947.375 -2.109 -4.535 1947.458 -2.301 -4.433 1947.542 -2.693 -4.330 1947.625 -2.536 -4.255 1947.708 -2.412 -4.436 1947.792 -2.469 -4.325 1947.875 -2.841 -4.229 1947.958 -2.855 -4.411 1948.042 -2.789 -4.360 1948.125 -2.684 -4.447 1948.208 -2.176 -4.295 1948.292 -1.311 -4.291 1948.375 -2.689 -4.701 1948.458 -2.817 -4.697 1948.542 -2.536 -4.443 1948.625 -2.475 -4.365 1948.708 -2.587 -4.349 1948.792 -2.583 -4.392 1948.875 -2.797 -4.564 1948.958 -2.668 -4.347 1949.042 -2.649 -4.246 1949.125 -2.767 -4.382 1949.208 -2.868 -4.401 1949.292 -1.759 -4.351 1949.375 -2.209 -4.361 1949.458 -2.445 -4.380 1949.542 -2.426 -4.379 1949.625 -2.772 -4.329 1949.708 -2.884 -4.254 1949.792 -2.868 -4.034 1949.875 -2.816 -4.038 1949.958 -3.043 -4.014 1950.042 -2.874 -4.114 1950.125 -3.060 -4.242 1950.208 -2.358 -3.961 1950.292 -1.550 -4.054 1950.375 -2.297 -4.332 1950.458 -2.529 -4.322 1950.542 -2.608 -4.448 1950.625 -2.814 -4.328 1950.708 -3.252 -4.413 1950.792 -2.806 -4.145 1950.875 -3.044 -4.248 1950.958 -3.192 -4.317 1951.042 -2.886 -4.453 1951.125 -2.681 -4.280 1951.208 -1.758 -4.061 1951.292 -1.562 -4.310 1951.375 -2.658 -4.784 1951.458 -2.360 -4.712 1951.542 -2.274 -4.709 1951.625 -2.252 -4.676 1951.708 -2.503 -4.615 1951.792 -2.386 -4.276 1951.875 -2.851 -4.548 1951.958 -2.690 -4.567 1952.042 -2.619 -4.366 1952.125 -2.746 -4.571 1952.208 -2.974 -4.609 1952.292 -2.016 -4.490 1952.375 -1.923 -4.430 1952.458 -2.444 -4.565 1952.542 -2.138 -4.513 1952.625 -2.119 -4.523 1952.708 -2.695 -4.381 1952.792 -2.731 -4.329 1952.875 -2.605 -4.353 1952.958 -2.817 -4.401 1953.042 -2.797 -4.438 1953.125 -2.799 -4.488 1953.208 -2.411 -4.327 1953.292 -1.393 -4.250 1953.375 -2.106 -4.641 1953.458 -2.563 -4.579 1953.542 -2.121 -4.656 1953.625 -2.370 -4.539 1953.708 -2.556 -4.525 1953.792 -2.669 -4.404 1953.875 -2.588 -4.485 1953.958 -2.684 -4.373 1954.042 -2.775 -4.437 1954.125 -3.066 -4.471 1954.208 -2.836 -4.372 1954.292 -1.552 -4.513 1954.375 -2.560 -4.470 1954.458 -2.610 -4.357 1954.542 -2.265 -4.429 1954.625 -2.314 -4.350 1954.708 -2.543 -4.361 1954.792 -2.817 -4.195 1954.875 -2.740 -4.191 1954.958 -2.704 -4.190 1955.042 -2.972 -4.321 1955.125 -2.893 -4.301 1955.208 -2.209 -4.274 1955.292 -1.528 -4.247 1955.375 -2.684 -4.438 1955.458 -2.596 -4.394 1955.542 -2.355 -4.380 1955.625 -2.482 -4.242 1955.708 -2.616 -4.141 1955.792 -2.499 -4.174 1955.875 -2.390 -4.239 1955.958 -2.436 -4.366 1956.042 -2.450 -4.402 1956.125 -2.365 -4.353 1956.208 -1.957 -4.497 1956.292 -1.625 -4.619 1956.375 -1.990 -4.700 1956.458 -1.796 -4.644 1956.542 -1.785 -4.631 1956.625 -2.177 -4.580 1956.708 -2.095 -4.526 1956.792 -1.878 -4.427 1956.875 -2.184 -4.410 1956.958 -2.405 -4.395 1957.042 -2.419 -4.505 1957.125 -2.207 -4.518 1957.208 -1.812 -4.407 1957.292 -0.559 -4.075 1957.375 -1.523 -4.609 1957.458 -1.146 -4.515 1957.542 -1.461 -4.564 1957.625 -1.603 -4.682 1957.708 -1.569 -4.669 1957.792 -1.786 -4.801 1957.875 -1.825 -4.770 1957.958 -2.081 -4.722 1958.042 -2.097 -4.720 1958.125 -1.528 -4.609 1958.208 -1.869 -4.664 1958.292 -1.331 -4.598 1958.375 -1.643 -4.561 1958.458 -1.720 -4.508 1958.542 -2.099 -4.568 1958.625 -2.046 -4.586 1958.708 -2.036 -4.524 1958.792 -2.163 -4.521 1958.875 -2.248 -4.554 1958.958 -1.651 -4.439 1959.042 -2.274 -4.500 1959.125 -2.517 -4.629 1959.208 -1.338 -4.335 1959.292 -0.541 -4.225 1959.375 -1.390 -4.466 1959.458 -1.699 -4.662 1959.542 -2.007 -4.613 1959.625 -1.981 -4.731 1959.708 -2.147 -4.596 1959.792 -2.285 -4.537 1959.875 -2.501 -4.417 1959.958 -2.513 -4.403 1960.042 -2.297 -4.321 1960.125 -2.267 -4.412 1960.208 -1.300 -4.092 1960.292 -0.030 -3.937 1960.375 -1.816 -4.465 1960.458 -1.951 -4.510 1960.542 -2.022 -4.471 1960.625 -2.106 -4.486 1960.708 -2.044 -4.414 1960.792 -1.663 -4.386 1960.875 -2.093 -4.398 1960.958 -2.216 -4.341 1961.042 -2.363 -4.465 1961.125 -2.139 -4.442 1961.208 -0.769 -4.015 1961.292 -0.631 -4.137 1961.375 -1.581 -4.475 1961.458 -1.580 -4.456 1961.542 -1.711 -4.397 1961.625 -1.985 -4.477 1961.708 -2.193 -4.432 1961.792 -2.313 -4.299 1961.875 -2.292 -4.298 1961.958 -2.655 -4.371 1962.042 -2.363 -4.548 1962.125 -2.340 -4.415 1962.208 -2.395 -4.361 1962.292 -1.386 -4.357 1962.375 -1.843 -4.476 1962.458 -1.822 -4.594 1962.542 -1.915 -4.448 1962.625 -2.131 -4.335 1962.708 -2.128 -4.330 1962.792 -2.352 -4.403 1962.875 -2.381 -4.392 1962.958 -2.161 -4.330 1963.042 -2.319 -4.420 1963.125 -2.169 -4.424 1963.208 -1.745 -4.322 1963.292 -0.331 -3.956 1963.375 -1.066 -4.409 1963.458 -2.274 -4.661 1963.542 -2.187 -4.667 1963.625 -2.018 -4.625 1963.708 -1.961 -4.686 1963.792 -2.274 -4.640 1963.875 -2.342 -4.644 1963.958 -2.458 -4.543 1964.042 -2.527 -4.498 1964.125 -2.558 -4.452 1964.208 -2.331 -4.497 1964.292 -2.344 -4.509 1964.375 -2.097 -4.460 1964.458 -2.228 -4.392 1964.542 -2.117 -4.422 1964.625 -2.066 -4.371 1964.708 -1.913 -4.274 1964.792 -2.048 -4.220 1964.875 -2.140 -4.222 1964.958 -2.281 -4.297 1965.042 -2.136 -4.209 1965.125 -1.346 -4.080 1965.208 -0.979 -4.035 1965.292 -0.774 -4.145 1965.375 -1.433 -4.537 1965.458 -2.195 -4.722 1965.542 -2.205 -4.793 1965.625 -2.039 -4.768 1965.708 -2.141 -4.702 1965.792 -2.263 -4.699 1965.875 -2.250 -4.513 1965.958 -2.264 -4.581 1966.042 -2.036 -4.434 1966.125 -2.216 -4.575 1966.208 -1.905 -4.402 1966.292 -0.988 -4.038 1966.375 -1.710 -4.363 1966.458 -1.609 -4.373 1966.542 -1.777 -4.316 1966.625 -1.911 -4.395 1966.708 -1.759 -4.364 1966.792 -2.074 -4.282 1966.875 -2.057 -4.160 1966.958 -2.332 -4.228 1967.042 -2.406 -4.244 1967.125 -2.256 -4.191 1967.208 -1.395 -3.961 1967.292 -0.689 -3.949 1967.375 -1.807 -4.338 1967.458 -1.601 -4.463 1967.542 -1.698 -4.470 1967.625 -1.945 -4.562 1967.708 -2.069 -4.514 1967.792 -2.403 -4.382 1967.875 -2.383 -4.306 1967.958 -2.324 -4.283 1968.042 -2.576 -4.318 1968.125 -2.205 -4.271 1968.208 -1.823 -4.016 1968.292 -1.030 -3.987 1968.375 -1.495 -4.340 1968.458 -1.808 -4.563 1968.542 -1.755 -4.600 1968.625 -1.912 -4.578 1968.708 -1.913 -4.608 1968.792 -2.212 -4.631 1968.875 -2.222 -4.706 1968.958 -2.409 -4.584 1969.042 -2.483 -4.634 1969.125 -2.524 -4.593 1969.208 -2.179 -4.558 1969.292 -0.865 -4.075 1969.375 -2.341 -4.472 1969.458 -2.244 -4.576 1969.542 -2.138 -4.598 1969.625 -2.097 -4.631 1969.708 -2.386 -4.591 1969.792 -2.430 -4.610 1969.875 -2.711 -4.590 1969.958 -2.234 -4.442 1970.042 -2.300 -4.596 1970.125 -2.788 -4.543 1970.208 -2.497 -4.494 1970.292 -1.807 -4.152 1970.375 -2.816 -4.458 1970.458 -2.468 -4.289 1970.542 -2.564 -4.286 1970.625 -2.535 -4.169 1970.708 -2.880 -4.185 1970.792 -2.779 -4.263 1970.875 -2.511 -4.118 1970.958 -2.710 -4.145 1971.042 -2.739 -4.193 1971.125 -2.907 -4.245 1971.208 -2.177 -4.013 1971.292 -1.366 -4.000 1971.375 -2.108 -4.335 1971.458 -2.218 -4.407 1971.542 -2.704 -4.479 1971.625 -2.496 -4.290 1971.708 -2.845 -4.347 1971.792 -2.955 -4.326 1971.875 -2.780 -4.395 1971.958 -2.798 -4.361 1972.042 -2.799 -4.351 1972.125 -2.339 -4.241 1972.208 -2.229 -4.180 1972.292 -1.214 -4.181 1972.375 -2.240 -4.695 1972.458 -2.421 -4.734 1972.542 -2.552 -4.704 1972.625 -2.349 -4.909 1972.708 -2.527 -5.060 1972.792 -2.872 -5.029 1972.875 -2.625 -4.835 1972.958 -2.775 -4.796 1973.042 -2.654 -4.617 1973.125 -2.603 -4.371 1973.208 -2.456 -4.483 1973.292 -2.407 -4.544 1973.375 -2.660 -4.404 1973.458 -2.937 -4.204 1973.542 -2.852 -4.308 1973.625 -2.631 -4.137 1973.708 -2.312 -4.039 1973.792 -2.499 -4.085 1973.875 -2.582 -4.072 1973.958 -2.587 -4.113 1974.042 -2.229 -4.228 1974.125 -2.031 -4.092 1974.208 -2.253 -4.138 1974.292 -1.517 -3.991 1974.375 -1.474 -4.134 1974.458 -2.186 -4.433 1974.542 -2.036 -4.374 1974.625 -2.412 -4.425 1974.708 -2.565 -4.453 1974.792 -2.573 -4.413 1974.875 -2.613 -4.357 1974.958 -2.508 -4.278 1975.042 -2.615 -4.375 1975.125 -2.463 -4.295 1975.208 -1.871 -4.021 1975.292 -1.085 -3.761 1975.375 -1.521 -3.977 1975.458 -2.105 -4.285 1975.542 -2.070 -4.205 1975.625 -2.335 -4.232 1975.708 -2.733 -4.283 1975.792 -2.967 -4.282 1975.875 -3.022 -4.263 1975.958 -2.821 -4.275 1976.042 -2.738 -4.264 1976.125 -2.930 -4.309 1976.208 -2.553 -4.260 1976.292 -1.029 -3.917 1976.375 -2.196 -4.590 1976.458 -2.852 -4.690 1976.542 -2.456 -4.651 1976.625 -2.460 -4.664 1976.708 -2.708 -4.723 1976.792 -3.041 -4.680 1976.875 -3.237 -4.731 1976.958 -3.126 -4.600 1977.042 -3.180 -4.527 1977.125 -2.734 -4.561 1977.208 -2.577 -4.526 1977.292 -0.461 -4.089 1977.375 -2.319 -4.616 1977.458 -2.281 -4.639 1977.542 -2.222 -4.671 1977.625 -2.459 -4.736 1977.708 -2.638 -4.695 1977.792 -2.582 -4.794 1977.875 -2.766 -4.630 1977.958 -2.971 -4.599 1978.042 -3.035 -4.624 1978.125 -3.181 -4.658 1978.208 -2.798 -4.709 1978.292 -2.769 -4.557 1978.375 -2.720 -4.602 1978.458 -2.427 -4.467 1978.542 -2.471 -4.462 1978.625 -2.661 -4.482 1978.708 -2.572 -4.566 1978.792 -2.813 -4.483 1978.875 -2.829 -4.530 1978.958 -2.593 -4.483 1979.042 -2.507 -4.486 1979.125 -2.793 -4.453 1979.208 -2.908 -4.399 1979.292 -0.846 -3.968 1979.375 -2.021 -4.505 1979.458 -2.438 -4.756 1979.542 -2.417 -4.714 1979.625 -2.816 -4.744 1979.708 -2.760 -4.745 1979.792 -2.661 -4.695 1979.875 -2.796 -4.556 1979.958 -2.719 -4.552 1980.042 -2.482 -4.451 1980.125 -2.562 -4.477 1980.208 -2.529 -4.485 1980.292 -0.432 -3.883 1980.375 -1.494 -4.261 1980.458 -2.334 -4.594 1980.542 -2.230 -4.690 1980.625 -2.249 -4.702 1980.708 -2.441 -4.717 1980.792 -2.846 -4.742 1980.875 -2.857 -4.738 1980.958 -2.872 -4.647 1981.042 -2.658 -4.452 1981.125 -2.491 -4.596 1981.208 -2.361 -4.552 1981.292 -1.062 -4.170 1981.375 -2.092 -4.407 1981.458 -2.433 -4.545 1981.542 -2.297 -4.601 1981.625 -2.526 -4.621 1981.708 -2.423 -4.591 1981.792 -2.409 -4.295 1981.875 -2.315 -4.568 1981.958 -2.877 -4.411 1982.042 -2.891 -4.535 1982.125 -2.860 -4.667 1982.208 -2.242 -4.535 1982.292 -0.632 -4.111 1982.375 -1.706 -4.605 1982.458 -1.685 -4.791 1982.542 -1.330 -4.750 1982.625 -1.621 -4.583 1982.708 -1.747 -4.781 1982.792 -2.100 -5.107 1982.875 -1.666 -5.050 1982.958 -1.842 -5.074 1983.042 -1.969 -5.017 1983.125 -2.360 -5.113 1983.208 -2.083 -5.072 1983.292 -2.154 -5.012 1983.375 -2.326 -4.944 1983.458 -2.340 -4.760 1983.542 -2.227 -4.659 1983.625 -2.420 -4.520 1983.708 -2.500 -4.479 1983.792 -2.717 -4.471 1983.875 -2.768 -4.436 1983.958 -2.505 -4.432 1984.042 -2.305 -4.392 1984.125 -2.602 -4.455 1984.208 -2.225 -4.359 1984.292 -0.596 -3.930 1984.375 -1.160 -4.245 1984.458 -2.104 -4.573 1984.542 -2.449 -4.606 1984.625 -2.824 -4.561 1984.708 -2.929 -4.563 1984.792 -2.697 -4.433 1984.875 -3.143 -4.430 1984.958 -2.658 -4.327 1985.042 -2.608 -4.359 1985.125 -2.596 -4.421 1985.208 -2.357 -4.456 1985.292 -0.856 -4.041 1985.375 -2.019 -4.543 1985.458 -2.461 -4.671 1985.542 -2.399 -4.641 1985.625 -2.400 -4.562 1985.708 -2.453 -4.684 1985.792 -2.711 -4.755 1985.875 -2.953 -4.589 1985.958 -2.761 -4.372 1986.042 -2.991 -4.602 1986.125 -2.504 -4.701 1986.208 -1.803 -4.480 1986.292 -0.981 -4.335 1986.375 -2.028 -4.857 1986.458 -2.252 -5.045 1986.542 -2.450 -5.006 1986.625 -2.373 -4.975 1986.708 -2.293 -4.965 1986.792 -2.582 -4.870 1986.875 -2.746 -4.863 1986.958 -2.869 -4.761 1987.042 -2.345 -4.844 1987.125 -2.482 -4.853 1987.208 -2.591 -4.828 1987.292 -0.279 -4.336 1987.375 -1.820 -4.799 1987.458 -1.890 -4.969 1987.542 -2.574 -5.077 1987.625 -2.953 -5.067 1987.708 -3.023 -4.958 1987.792 -2.834 -5.021 1987.875 -2.968 -4.723 1987.958 -3.349 -4.720 1988.042 -3.183 -4.703 1988.125 -2.130 -4.488 1988.208 -2.305 -4.558 1988.292 -1.958 -4.486 1988.375 -2.499 -4.534 1988.458 -2.242 -4.460 1988.542 -2.700 -4.338 1988.625 -3.056 -4.192 1988.708 -2.872 -4.144 1988.792 -3.153 -4.434 1988.875 -2.739 -4.255 1988.958 -2.813 -4.249 1989.042 -2.948 -4.418 1989.125 -2.707 -4.364 1989.208 -2.388 -4.424 1989.292 -1.160 -4.207 1989.375 -2.147 -4.647 1989.458 -2.486 -4.676 1989.542 -2.462 -4.692 1989.625 -2.784 -4.700 1989.708 -3.048 -4.666 1989.792 -3.038 -4.695 1989.875 -2.731 -4.694 1989.958 -2.861 -4.697 1990.042 -2.541 -4.635 1990.125 -2.743 -4.670 1990.208 -2.003 -4.688 1990.292 -1.664 -4.627 1990.375 -2.556 -4.898 1990.458 -2.378 -4.872 1990.542 -2.199 -4.885 1990.625 -2.330 -4.881 1990.708 -2.645 -4.811 1990.792 -2.594 -4.739 1990.875 -2.692 -4.795 1990.958 -2.653 -4.773 1991.042 -2.545 -4.794 1991.125 -2.460 -4.840 1991.208 -2.383 -4.728 1991.292 -0.982 -4.434 1991.375 -2.657 -5.000 1991.458 -2.607 -4.970 1991.542 -2.571 -4.963 1991.625 -2.297 -4.911 1991.708 -2.255 -5.106 1991.792 -2.762 -5.113 1991.875 -2.830 -5.114 1991.958 -2.352 -5.139 1992.042 -2.661 -5.094 1992.125 -2.528 -5.099 1992.208 -2.726 -4.981 1992.292 -2.182 -5.017 1992.375 -2.605 -4.808 1992.458 -2.900 -4.806 1992.542 -2.958 -4.778 1992.625 -2.923 -4.717 1992.708 -3.010 -4.795 1992.792 -3.125 -4.847 1992.875 -2.785 -4.717 1992.958 -2.793 -4.663 1993.042 -2.924 -4.734 1993.125 -2.855 -4.857 1993.208 -2.863 -4.891 1993.292 -1.915 -4.678 1993.375 -3.627 -5.164 1993.458 -3.487 -5.079 1993.542 -3.176 -4.928 1993.625 -3.158 -5.088